Buyer Beware
Hello,
Insurance companies have an interesting advertising strategy. They don't spend much time convincing us to buy insurance. Instead, they convince us to remember them. Flo. Mayhem. The GEICO cavemen. Jake from State Farm. Dr. Rick. We may not remember what they're selling in a particular commercial, but we almost always remember who they are.
For the past couple of years, almost every night, I stream an episode of House Hunters. Twenty minutes of people insisting they need more natural light or debating whether they can live without a farmhouse sink somehow signals to my brain that it's time to go to sleep. It's my technological melatonin.
There was a month or so earlier this year when every episode started with one of two different GEICO commercials. One featured a woman digging through her couch cushions looking for the remote. Instead, she found a potato chip that vaguely resembled Vincent van Gogh. Her husband picked it up and said, "Vincent Van Gone." I still have no idea what that had to do with insurance or why a potato chip was more surprising to her than a talking gecko.
The second commercial, however, really got me thinking.
A husband and wife are standing in their bathroom looking at a clogged sink.
The GEICO gecko emerges from the drain wearing tiny snorkel gear, holding the wife's missing earring. He explains that the earring was clogging the drain, but then says he's going back down because he saw something he didn't like the look of. He keeps talking, using what sounds like plumbing terminology, but between his accent and the unfamiliar language, it's almost impossible to understand him.
The husband smiles, nods along, and tells the gecko to be safe down there. The wife turns to him and asks, "Did you understand what he said?"
"Nope," he replies. "Not a word."
The first time I saw the commercial, I assumed I was the only one who didn't know what the gecko had said. I figured I simply hadn't been paying attention. After seeing it over and over again, I realized that no one is supposed to understand the gecko. Once again, I wasn't sure what that had to do with insurance, but I don't work in advertising.
What eventually caught my attention wasn't the gecko. It wasn't even the dialogue. It was the husband and wife. They possessed exactly the same information. Neither understood what the gecko was saying. Yet if you paused the commercial just before the wife asked her question, I suspect most of us would assume the husband understood perfectly. He was smiling. He was nodding. He encouraged the gecko as though he completely followed the conversation. He didn't. He simply had a better poker face.
This commercial reminded me of a time interviewing candidates for a new position. Before the application deadline, two women reached out to ask questions. One wanted to discuss the schedule. The position required an earlier start time than her current role, and she thoughtfully explained how that might affect her family. Her teenage sons were obviously old enough to get themselves ready in the morning, and her husband would be home, but she still wasn't sure she could consistently commit to that start time five days a week since she was the morning motivator who made sure everyone made it out the door on time. She wanted to know whether there was any flexibility. When she realized she wouldn't be able to support her family in the way she wanted, she decided not to proceed to the interview round.
The second woman arrived with a list of questions she had prepared after carefully reading the posting. Every question referred to something specific in the job description. She had clearly done her homework and wanted to make sure she understood exactly what the position entailed.
A man applied as well. What caught my attention was that the posting listed certifications that were either required or strongly preferred. He had neither.
During the interview, we asked each candidate to share what excited them most about the position and what intimidated them the most. Without hesitation, the male candidate identified the part of the job he had never done before as the aspect he found most exciting.
Certainly, no one's questions or choices were right or wrong, but I was fascinated by the difference in approaches between the women and the man. I wish I had the chutzpah to apply for a position that I don't have the certification for and say the part of the job that most excites me is the part I'm least familiar with. The best I have is to tell myself to apply for the positon and let the hiring committee figure out that I'm not the right person.
For years, we've heard some version of the "confidence gap," the idea that women are less confident than men professionally. The classic example of the confidence gap is often illustrated by the claim that men apply for jobs when they meet only some of the qualifications while women wait until they meet nearly all of them. The exact numbers have become the subject of considerable debate, and some of the statistics most often repeated don't appear to have much evidence behind them.
I'm less interested in the percentages than in something I've observed over hundreds, maybe thousands, of interviews. Men and women often communicate uncertainty differently. Many women ask clarifying questions before deciding they're ready and admit their lack of experience. For example, when answering an interview question about a situation they have no direct experience in, women will say, "I haven't done that before..."
Men, on the other hand, when asked the same question, are more likely to answer, "In my experience..." even when they don't have it as it relates to the specific situation. In other words, many men seem more comfortable projecting certainty. Sometimes that's earned confidence. Sometimes it's optimism. Sometimes it's simply a willingness to learn by doing. And sometimes it's just a better poker face.
I don't think this is really about men and women. I think it's about the expectations society attaches to different roles. It's socially expected for men to know how to fix things around the house, so admitting they don't can feel like admitting they've failed at being a man. We expect leaders to have answers. We expect experts to sound certain. Those expectations don't just shape how other people see us. They shape how we think we're supposed to present ourselves.
The problem is that no one begins as an expert. Every expert was once the person asking the questions, making mistakes, and admitting they didn't know. When we confuse confidence with competence, we unintentionally discourage the very behaviors that lead to genuine competence in the first place.
Research on overconfidence supports what many of us instinctively recognize. Confidence is easy to see, so we often mistake it for competence. In reality, the relationship between the two is much weaker than we'd like to believe.
As leaders, that distinction matters. Every interview, every promotion, and every opportunity requires us to judge someone's potential. If we rely too heavily on confidence, we'll reward the people with the best poker faces instead of the people asking the best questions.
If a confident fifteen-year-old told you they were ready to drive, would you hand them the keys simply because they believed they could do it? Of course not. Confidence has never been a substitute for competence.
Now imagine you're riding in a car during a snowstorm. Which driver would you trust? The one who insists the roads are fine because they've "got this," or the one who says, "These conditions are beyond my comfort level. I'm going to pull over until they improve."
Maybe that's why insurance companies don't ask us how confident we are.
~Heather
P.S. Sometimes the most interesting lesson isn't the one a documentary sets out to teach. It's the one you discover along the way.
That is why my Catch of the Week this week is the Amazon documentary Murder 101.
The documentary follows a high school sociology class whose students become involved in investigating real cold cases. While I don't think it's necessarily the strongest example of learning sociology, I was fascinated by something else. The moment the students realized their work could actually matter beyond the classroom, the nature of their learning changed.
There's a world of difference between completing an assignment for a teacher and contributing work that could make a meaningful difference in someone else's life. When the audience becomes authentic, students ask better questions, think more critically, and persist through challenges because the work has purpose beyond earning a grade.
The catch is this: one of the most powerful ways to increase engagement isn't by making learning more entertaining. It's by making it matter. When students know someone beyond their teacher is depending on the quality of their work, they often surprise themselves with what they're capable of accomplishing.
P.P.S. Please remember to...
Like and share this post
Check out other posts
Subscribe to www.lyonsletters.com
Buy and rate your copy of Engagement is Not Unicorn (It's a Narwhal),
From Amazon or Barnes & Noble




Comments